FBI obtains new emails related to Clinton investigation — and they came from investigation into Anthony Weiner’s sexting
The FBI said Friday it would reopen its investigation into Hillary Clinton’s private email server after learning of “the existence of emails that appear to be pertinent to the investigation” — emails that officials later said were discovered amid an inquiry into former Congressman Anthony Weiner.
James Comey, FBI Director, send a letter to congressional leaders, said the team in charge of looking into Clinton’s server briefed him Thursday on new emails it found “in connection with an unrelated case.”
“The FBI cannot yet evaluate whether or not these elements may be meaningful,” Comey composed. “I cannot predict how long it will take us to complete this additional work.”
The emails were revealed after the FBI seized devices referring to Huma Abedin and her husband, Weiner, The New York Times stated, telling law enforcement administrators. Prosecutors announced a subpoena for Weiner’s cellphone and other records in late September amid accusations that he had been sexting with a 15-year-old teenager girl.
Abedin is one of Clinton’s top aides. She and Weiner left in late August after The New York Post stated that Weiner sent evocative images and messages to a woman for more than one year beginning in early 2015.
A federal official said The Times on Friday that some emails revealed through Abedin’s and Weiner’s things was in the thousands. The emails included were apparently sent and received by Abedin over an extended period.
The developments started a wrench into an already violent presidential campaign with just 11 days before Election Day, coming as Clinton has held guidance over Republican nominee Donald Trump in national polls and reviews in key battleground events.
Clinton talked at a rally on Friday after the news broke, but did not mention the FBI’s announcement. In a statement later Friday, Clinton campaign chair John Podesta called on the FBI and Comey to clarify its statement.
“It is extraordinary that we would see something like this just 11 days out from a presidential election,” Podesta said. “The Director owes it to the American people to immediately provide the full details of what he is now examining. We are confident this will not produce any conclusions different from the one the FBI reached in July.”
Commodities fell clearly after the FBI’s statement.
Trump seized to the news at a rally Friday, saying Clinton’s “corruption is not on a scale we have ever seen.
“The FBI and the Justice Department now have the chance to right the horrible mistake that they made” in not previously recommending that Clinton is charged with criminal wrongdoing, he added.
House Speaker Paul Ryan released a statement renewing his call for the director of national intelligence to suspend classified intelligence briefings for Clinton, who “was entrusted with some of our nation’s most important secrets, and betrayed that trust by carelessly mishandling highly classified information,” he said.
On Twitter, some political analysts and observers condemned the FBI’s handling of the announcement.
“It’s bad enough having the media do the ‘raises questions,’ substance-free innuendo thing. Worse when the FBI director does it. Disgraceful,” Paul Krugman, the economist and New York Times columnist, wrote on Twitter. “Comey needs to provide full info immediately. Otherwise he has clearly made a partisan intervention, betraying his office.”
“I have zero faith that anyone will handle this responsibly,” former Obama speechwriter Jon Favreau wrote. “It’s insane. [Comey] at least owes the country a press briefing — anything more than a vague letter.”
“Director Comey should give a more complete explanation. Is this reviewing newly found emails? Is this reopening? Too much at stake,” wrote John Weaver, the former campaign strategist for Ohio Gov. John Kasich.
Clinton’s email scandal has dogged the Democratic presidential nominee for more than a year. In March 2015, she first admitted to exclusively using a private email account to send and receive work-related emails while she served as secretary of state. The controversy compelled her to hand over roughly 30,000 work-related emails to the State Department, which have been released in batches since last year.
But she deleted about 30,000 additional emails from her server that she said were “personal” in nature before handing it over to the FBI in August, five months after she gave individual emails to the State Department.
NBC’s Pete Williams reported Friday that the newly discovered emails were not among those originally withheld by Clinton or her campaign, and were found on a “device” in a separate investigation. The decision to reopen the investigation was not related to emails released by WikiLeaks or to Russian hacking, Williams said.
A US official also told The Associated Press that the newly discovered emails relating to the FBI’s Clinton investigation did not come from her private server.
After examining her emails for more than a year, the State Department issued a scathing report in May concluding that she “did not comply” with its policies when she chose to use a personal email account to conduct government business.
The State Department faulted Clinton and previous secretaries of state for poorly managing email and other computer information and for slowly responding to new cyber security risks.
Two months later, the FBI decided not to recommend that the Justice Department bring charges against Clinton, saying Clinton’s conduct did not meet the threshold used to prosecute past violators who shared classified information over unclassified channels.
“In looking back at our investigations into mishandling or removal of classified information, we cannot find a case that would support bringing criminal charges on these facts,” Comey said in July, after the FBI interviewed Clinton for three hours about her use of the server while at the State Department.
Trump has called the FBI’s determination “very unfair” and has said that if he were elected president, he would “lock her up” over her email scandal.
Clinton’s unusual email system was originally set up by a staffer during Clinton’s 2008 presidential campaign. It replaced another private server used by her husband, Bill Clinton.
The new server was run by Bryan Pagliano, who had worked as the IT director on Hillary Clinton’s campaign before she joined the State Department in May 2009. In 2013 — the same year she left the State Department — Clinton hired Platte River Networks, a small Denver-based IT firm, to oversee the system.
Clinton has since apologized for using the email server and insisted she never sent or received information marked “classified” using her private email account.
The news tops off a particularly turbulent week for the Clinton campaign in the campaign’s final days.
It included the release of a hacked memo published by WikiLeaks titled “Bill Clinton, Inc.” that raised questions about the blurring of lines between the Clinton Foundation charity and the Clintons’ personal finances. And the Obama administration confirmed this week that health insurance premiums on the exchanges set up by the Affordable Care Act were set to increase significantly in 2017.